Harvard affirms President Claudine Gay will not step down over antisemitism testimony
Updated December 12, 2023 at 11:03 AM ET
The highest governing board of Harvard University says that President Claudine Gay will remain in office, rejecting calls that she be removed after her congressional testimony on antisemitism sparked outrage among lawmakers, alumni and donors.
"Our extensive deliberations affirm our confidence that President Gay is the right leader to help our community heal and to address the very serious societal issues we are facing," the board, known as the Harvard Corporation, said on Tuesday.
Calls for Gay's removal erupted after she was asked by Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., at a hearing of the House Committee on Education last week whether calling for the "genocide of Jews" violated Harvard's rules on bullying and harassment. Gay replied, "It can be, depending on the context."
When asked to clarify, Gay said, "Antisemitic rhetoric, when it crosses into conduct that amounts to bullying, harassment, intimidation — that is actionable conduct and we do take action."
Stefanik — a 2006 graduate of Harvard — repeatedly grilled Gay about her views during the Dec. 5 hearing, as her House colleagues yielded part of their time to her.
University leaders have been hit by fallout from Dec. 5 hearing
The decision by Harvard's governing board follows the announcement on Saturday by Liz Magill, the president of the University of Pennsylvania, that she is resigning following backlash to her testimony before the House.
Magill, Gay and Sally Kornbluth of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology were each called to testify about antisemitism on college campuses, and in sometimes heated testimony faced criticism for a lack of moral clarity for responses that were seen as overly legalistic. While Kornbluth has received support from MIT's board, she still faces some calls to step down from lawmakers in response to her testimony.
Critics said the Harvard president's answers fell short and cast doubt on whether Gay was equipped to protect the university's Jewish students at a moment of rising antisemitism stemming from the war in Gaza. In an interview with The Harvard Crimson two days after the hearing, Gay apologized for her remarks.
"I got caught up in what had become at that point, an extended, combative exchange about policies and procedures," she said to the Crimson. "What I should have had the presence of mind to do in that moment was return to my guiding truth, which is that calls for violence against our Jewish community — threats to our Jewish students — have no place at Harvard, and will never go unchallenged."
In a separate statement on social media, Gay said, "Let me be clear: Calls for violence or genocide against the Jewish community, or any religious or ethnic group are vile, they have no place at Harvard."
Pressure has been building on Gay, and Harvard
Despite Gay's apology, criticism over her leadership continued to mount in the days after the congressional hearing. On Friday, over 70 members of Congress called for her departure, as well as the removal of UPenn's Magill and MIT's Kornbluth. Those concerns were echoed by some Harvard faculty members, students and alumni, including billionaire investor Bill Ackman, who on Sunday sent a scathing letter to his alma mater's governing boards, accusing Gay of damaging the university's reputation.
"Knowing what we know now, would Harvard consider Claudine Gay for the position? The answer is definitively 'No,'" he wrote, adding that the decision of whether to fire Gay "could not be more straightforward."
Despite the backlash, Gay has also received widespread support from students and faculty members. By Monday, more than 700 faculty members had signed a letter to Harvard's top governing body, urging it to keep Gay as president. The letter warned that such political pressure for Gay's removal is "at odds with Harvard's commitment to academic freedom."
"The critical work of defending a culture of free inquiry in our diverse community cannot proceed if we let its shape be dictated by outside forces," the letter said, according to Alison Frank Johnson, a history professor at Harvard who co-authored it.
Gay made history this past summer as the first person of color and second woman ever to become president of Harvard.
As it affirmed her continued tenure, the board stated, "In this tumultuous and difficult time, we unanimously stand in support of President Gay."
Her congressional testimony was not the first time Gay became embroiled in controversy since the Israel-Hamas war broke out. In October, Gay was criticized for not condemning Hamas more quickly or in strong enough terms, as well as not swiftly reprimanding students who in a letter accused Israel of being "entirely responsible for all unfolding violence."
Following the outrage, Gay said in a video that she wholeheartedly condemned the "barbaric atrocities perpetrated by Hamas." She also emphasized grace and freedom of speech.
Gay was also rebuked by pro-Palestinian faculty members after she condemned the chant "from the river to the sea," which has been evoked by militant groups like Hamas to call for the erasure of Israel.
Board also addresses plagiarism reports
As Gay's remarks before Congress put her under close public scrutiny, reports have also emerged of potential plagiarism in her published work on political science, her academic field — including in her dissertation at Harvard. The allegations, which drew notice on Sunday and Monday, relate to the years before Gay assumed her post leading Harvard.
As it reiterated its support for Gay, the board also weighed in on the plagiarism allegations. The board said that while it found "a few instances of inadequate citation," Gay's actions did not violate its research standards. Even so, it said, corrections will be added to the work.
"President Gay is proactively requesting four corrections in two articles to insert citations and quotation marks that were omitted from the original publications," the board stated.
The board didn't identify the articles in question. On Monday, conservative website the Washington Free Beacon reported that it found problems in four of Gay's published papers, saying for instance that in her 1997 dissertation, Gay borrowed sections of text from earlier work by a classmate and a professor at Harvard, without attribution.
Some of the examples raised by the Free Beacon and by conservative writers Christopher and Chris Brunet in a story on Substack, are cases in which Gay repeated words and phrases that appeared in others' work while citing the source — but without adding quotation marks. But student newspaper The Harvard Crimson, which reviewed the work in question, notes that other similarities "are more substantial, including some paragraphs and sentences nearly identical to other work and lacking citations." [Copyright 2023 NPR]
